All articles
black-nickelfinish-explainerinhouse

What Color Is Black Nickel, and Why Brushed Black Nickel Can Arrive Silver

A cool charcoal with a mirror shine. Add the word brushed and the color depends on which maker named it.

Black nickel is a deep charcoal with a cool, silvery cast and a high, wet-looking shine: dark like iron, reflective like polished nickel. It is not black in the way matte black or a black-painted knob is black, because the surface is metal plating rather than a colored coat, and it throws back light the way any polished metal does. One thing changes the answer, and it catches more buyers than the color does: brushed black nickel is not simply a duller version of the same finish, and depending on the maker it can arrive mostly silver.

Shop the finish

Every brushed black nickel knob and pull we carry, in one place — filter by size, style, and brand.

Browse Brushed Black Nickel Cabinet Hardware →

What black nickel actually is

Black nickel is a nickel-based plating made dark during the plating process, normally laid over a layer of bright nickel. In the versions I have looked at, the dark color comes from the plating itself rather than from a painted or sprayed coat, though how a finish is made varies by product and manufacturer. That is why its color tends to have depth to it: the dark layer is thin and glassy, and the metal underneath still lends it a silver undertone you can see along an edge or on the curve of a knob. In most lines the cast is cool, a blue-gray charcoal rather than a brown one, so it belongs with the cool-metal family of chrome, polished nickel and stainless steel rather than with bronze. The closest everyday comparison I can offer is wet slate: dark, cool, and shining.

The lights you cook by push it further in one direction or the other. Under cool LEDs, 4000 K and above, black nickel goes noticeably blue-black. Under warm 2700 K bulbs it softens toward a neutral charcoal and loses some of that blue. If your kitchen runs on cool under-cabinet strips, expect the bluer version, and decide whether the room around it can carry that much blue.

Brushed black nickel can mean two different finishes

Catalogs make this confusing, and I would settle it before choosing anything else. Plain black nickel is generally the polished, dark, reflective version described above. Add the word brushed and the result depends on who made it. Berenson, for one, describes its brushed black nickel as a warm silver with black worked into the brushing, a two-tone effect that reads much lighter than plain black nickel. Amerock uses the reversed name, black brushed nickel, for a finish it describes as dark with silver glints, and also sells it paired with black nickel as a split, two-tone pull.

So two finish names one word-swap apart can describe a silver pull with dark grain and a dark pull with silver grain. Neither maker is wrong; finish names in this trade belong to whoever coined them. What it means for you is that a photograph of brushed black nickel tells you little until you know which maker's version you are looking at, and if you combine two brands' brushed black nickel in one kitchen, compare the physical pieces side by side first.

Black nickel next to the other dark finishes

Most people asking this question are really choosing among four or five dark finishes that look alike in a thumbnail. Here is how they differ in the hand.

Finish Color Sheen How it is made How it wears
Black nickel Cool charcoal, silver undertone High, reflective Dark nickel plating on most lines; varies by maker Varies by product and maker
Brushed black nickel Varies by maker, from silver with dark grain to dark with silver grain Low to medium, grained Typically plating, then brushed; varies by maker Varies by product and maker; grain can help disguise light wear
Gunmetal Dark gray, leans blue or brown by brand Soft glow Plating, PVD or coating, by maker Depends on the method
Matte black Flat black, no metal showing Little to none Usually powder coat or e-coat Can wear through at edges on cheap hardware
Oil-rubbed bronze Dark brown-black with copper highlights Low Applied dark finish; method varies by brand On many brands, lightens where hands touch

The nearest neighbor is gunmetal, and the useful distinction is sheen and temperature. Black nickel is the cooler and shinier of the two, with a crisp reflection; gunmetal glows rather than reflects and can tip warm in some brands. With a chrome faucet, black nickel's higher shine is a natural pairing; with a brushed nickel or stainless faucet, gunmetal's lower sheen sits closer to it. Matte black is a different kind of thing entirely, a coat of color with no metal showing, and next to black nickel it looks flat and slightly chalky. Oil-rubbed bronze belongs to another temperature family altogether: it is brown, and beside black nickel the brown becomes obvious in a way it rarely is when you see it alone.

Where black nickel earns its shine

My recommendation: choose black nickel when you want dark hardware in a kitchen that already has gloss in it. High-gloss or lacquered doors, glass uppers, polished stone, a chrome or polished nickel faucet, stainless appliances. In that company a matte black pull looks like the one dull object in the room, while black nickel reads as dark hardware that belongs to the same polished family. It is especially good against white and pale gray doors, where the dark color gives contrast and the shine keeps the pull from reading as a hole in the door.

The situations that change the call are specific. Black nickel can also work with a warm brass, champagne bronze or gold faucet, or with matte cabinetry and honed counters, when the combination is intentional: the cool, shiny metal then reads as a deliberate contrast. If you would rather have a calmer dark finish in those rooms, oil-rubbed bronze or matte black are the alternatives to compare. On dark cabinets, charcoal, navy or deep green, black nickel has less contrast and tends to show up as a glint.

What black nickel costs you

A glossy dark surface shows every fingerprint as a pale smudge, more plainly than a brushed or matte finish does. On a pull you open every time you cook, that means wiping it, and a household with small children may prefer matte black or a brushed finish for that reason alone. How a black nickel finish wears depends on the product and the manufacturer, so ask about the specific line you are considering, especially for the drawers that see the hardest use.

The last cost is matching. Black nickel shade varies between makers, and photographs make it worse, because the same pull can look gray or black depending on what was reflected in it when the picture was taken. Order the whole kitchen from one line in a single order, with a spare or two. Order a sample first: samples are sold at the regular price and can be credited on a qualifying order (see our sample policy). Hold it next to your faucet under your own lights, not against the cabinet alone, and compare the physical samples in your own lighting before you decide.

Black nickel cabinet pulls: does the shape change the color?

Yes, more than with most finishes. Rounded and curved pulls catch reflections along their whole length, so they read lighter and shinier; flat-faced bar pulls catch less light and look closer to black. If you want black nickel to look like metal rather than a dark stripe, choose a profile with some curve to it.

Are black and brushed nickel cabinet pulls the same as black nickel?

No. Those are two-tone pulls, a black body with brushed nickel on the face or the ends, and they read as two separate colors rather than one dark metal. If that contrast is what caught your eye, our piece on two-tone nickel and black pulls covers how to use them.

Shop Black Nickel Cabinet Hardware

Browse all 63 in Black Nickel Cabinet Hardware → Cabinet knobs Cabinet pulls & handles

Shop the guide →